With the scandal
in Atlanta so recently in the news, I thought about some of the stories I have
heard, similar to my own, about teachers who have suffered in the hands of the
testing machine. On this blog, I will occasionally share stories of teachers who left school systems "poorly." Names of people and schools have been changed to protect
anyone involved, directly or indirectly. Because the first story is so close
to my own, I named the teacher Ms. Stokley.
Ms. Stokley
Nothing in education surprises me anymore, most especially what happened in Atlanta. My last year of grade school teaching was at the prestigious St. Cassian School, which sits in the most affluent neighborhood in my city. The school offers the very best of benefits including catered lunches and a state-of-the-art computer lab. Most of the students were from wealthy and influential families. When I arrived in 2002, another English teacher warned me, "You will think they are gems until you start breathing coal dust." She left me with that. I wish I had gone with her. The 8th grade class not only out-witted me, they cost me my career.
Most kids in the 8th grade
English class were headstrong, and worse, arrogant. They could care less about
present and past participles, favoring instead Spring Formal and the next St Cassian
School social event. Homework seemed to be optional. If they bothered with it
at all, it was taken from David, the only hopeful scholar in the group, and
copied word for word. I kept warning them that the zeros for homework would
count. Their incredulous glares spoke their opinion and intention, but I didn’t begin to realize what these kids were
capable of until one of them, Sam, asked to see me after class one Monday.
“Ms. Stokley,” he said, “You don’t seem to
understand how we learn.”
“Don’t I?” I asked, wondering who he had
heard this from.
“No. You give all these stupid
assignments, busy work, which you seem to lose or never grade, but we don’t
know anything new.”
“You are speaking for all of your
classmates?” I asked.
“Yeah, I am. I’m the only one not afraid.”
“Afraid? Your classmates are afraid of
me?”
Laughing, he said, “No, not of you. Of
consequences. Of failing English 8 when
you get angry, which happens all the time.”
“I’m not angry all the time, Sam. The
assignments you deem so stupid will help you review for the high school
entrance exam. You are planning to go to St Albert’s next year, right?”
Walking to the door, he said, “You don’t seem to get what I’m saying to
you, Ms. Stokley.”
I
didn’t “get it.” He was a 14 year old, after all. Not until a month later, when
I was called to the vice principal’s office, did I understand the warning. The
VP, Mrs. Elliot, new to the post, was degreed in
early childhood education. Her poor understanding of teenagers led to what happened.
“Ms. Stokley, I have concerns that you hold
biases against some of the students in the 8th grade class.”
“I disagree,” I said. “The 8th
grade class is a very intelligent group who spends their time avoiding assignments. I don’t dislike any of them, but I do expect them to complete
assignments. Has there been a complaint?”
“Yes. Sam came to see me. He said that he
hasn’t been given back any of his homework assignments, and that you don’t seem
to care if he passes or fails. Most troubling, he said that he is intimidated
by you because you get angry all the time. He’s scared to ask for help when he
doesn’t understand a grammar concept.”
God help me, I chuckled. What an ingenious plan, I thought.
“Forgive me, Mrs. Elliot. I believe Sam is very capable of any assignment I
give him. His test score on the standardized test is one of the lowest in the
class, so he needs to spend more time with English, but he is a very
intelligent, capable student.”
Well, I have to say, Ms. Stokley. Your
laughter seems to prove his concerns. I am appalled by it. This is a serious
matter. Do you have a problem with his race?”
“Oh, please don’t misunderstand. I am not
laughing at him. I am impressed by his maneuvering. He couldn’t persuade me to
excuse him from the work, so he came to you to force my hand.”
“He says he did the work.”
“No, ma’am. He didn’t. He never does.”
“Perhaps you have misplaced it.”
“No ma’am. I haven’t. He never gave it to
me.”
“Everyone, including you, can make
mistakes.”
“But I haven’t in this case. He never gave
it to me.”
Mrs. Elliot lowered her head slightly. “Ms.
Stokley, I think the error is yours, and I have written a citation for your
employee file. Your behavior is prejudiced and unprofessional. This explains
why 30% of our 8th graders failed their entrance exam to St. Albert’s.
I protested. “I have been teaching this
group for three months, and you are holding me responsible for their entire
education?”
“Just
what have you been teaching them? All of the students who failed the test were
A students until they reached your class.”
“I follow the curriculum guide to the
letter. It’s true that I have to spend a little more time on some concepts.”
“You couldn’t be. You produced failing
grades.”
Stunned,
I left Mrs. Elliot’s office without signing my citation. She had effectively called
me a liar. I kept teaching the 8th grade class as best as I could,
but it was the most miserable year in my career. The students refused to give any effort, and attempts to contact their parents failed. At the end of the year, I was
summoned back to the office, this time with the principal, Mrs. Mitchell.
“Well, Ms. Stokley, as you know we are in
the middle of offering contracts for next year. I have decided not to offer you
a contract based on your prejudiced views and inaccurate record keeping, both
of which have irreparably damaged some in our student population. In short, you
are being fired.”
Quietly, she let that sink in and
added, “You have the option of resigning. If you choose to resign, I will
remove the citation from your record. No
other school needs to know about it.
Fighting tears, I said, “You have accused
me of something I am not guilty of, Mrs. Mitchell. An accusation like that will
end my career. You know that I am under the alternative route to licensure. If
I don’t teach in the same school system for another year, I lose more than just
a job.”
“That’s very unfortunate. Perhaps
you can go to the public school system. Did you bring your laptop?”
She
couldn’t have heard me. I will not teach at all, anywhere! I
wanted to scream. Instead, I answered, “Yes, ma’am.
“Good. I have a list of names who have
reported you. You will change the 0s to 100s now. It will make the remaining of
the year go smoothly.”
Thinking she meant to fire me immediately
if I didn’t comply, I changed the grades, reducing myself to a liar, which I
learned didn’t matter in the eyes of the Church as long as the dishonesty fell
to their favor.
In October of the next academic year, I
found a job at a career college teaching medical assistants how to write well
enough to maintain their jobs. For a number of years, I tried to return to
grade school. I even enlisted the aid of my senator, to no avail.
The scandal in Atlanta doesn’t surprise me
at all, but before anyone starts burning teachers at the stake, consider
everyone involved. High stakes testing makes sinners of everyone.